Challenge your expectations with the Thursday Challenger. An attainable Urban Logger.

ZelieDad17 days ago
Thursday ChallengerMaryam Natural Horsebutt Overdyed Black
View album

Maker

Thursday

Model

Challenger

Leather

Last

Zeus Last

US Men's Brannock: 11.5D

Zeus Last: 11D

Sole

Heel

Purchased from

Thursday

More about this item

Awesome boots, awesome leather, awesome price.

Why I own this

Ready To Wear
Style
Outdoor Activities

I wanted the Nicks Urban Logger, but didn't want to wait. Saw these in a teacore veg tan, and pulled the trigger. I figured these would be a good stepping stone to the ULs, but I've fallen in love with them.

How I sized

Zeus Last: 11DUS Men's Brannock: 11.5D
Online Guide
Brannock Measurements

Thursday recommends half size down from Brannock. Did that. Perfect.

Ordering process

Purchased from ThursdayLead time: 6 days
Online Store
Shipping

Ordered on Christmas Day, got them the following week.

Use & wear

Outdoor Activities
Office Work
Leisure
Cold Temperatures
Hot Temperatures
Humid Climate
Wet Conditions
Snow

I wore these boots nearly everyday since I got them in January 2025. They've been in snow, rain, mud, and ice, and have held up better than I expected. Walks through my neighborhood, hikes in the woods, and general everyday use.

Leather

Maryam Natural Horsebutt Overdyed Black
Patina Process
Care Routine
Break-In
Breathability
Color Change

Originally the leather was stuff, but has broken in well. The black has started wearing away to reveal the natural tan below in higher wear areas, like the heel counter area, toe cap, sides, and on top where the boot bends when walking. I've conditioned them one after three months, but other than the occasional brushing I haven't done much. The leather itself is super tough and has only shown a few scratches here and there, and I appreciate how relatively thin the horserump is. Not too thick, or thin, just right for all day wear and now it's summer, my feet aren't roasting in them.

Fit

Zeus Last: 11DUS Men's Brannock: 11.5D
Comfort
Arch
Toe Box
Instep
Heel
Length Feels Right
Volume Feels Right
Ball Feels Right
Satisfied with the Fit

I think the fir is pretty good. As the leather has broken in, I've had to tighten them up a bit. In reality, if they offered a C width I would probably get that and let the leather expand to give a tighter fit. The toe box has plenty of room, 11 is my perfect size. My only complaint is that I wish the heel counter was a bit stiffer.

Craftsmanship

Thursday Challenger
Design
Construction
Finishing
Durability
Stitching
Lining

They are basically a take on Nicks Urban Loggers. They look great, feel great, and I've had 0 issues. The only minor issue I've had is the right boot developed a squeak, but that has gone away with wear and time.

Sole & heel

Vibram V1007 months, current sole
Traction
Comfort

It's hard. Good traction on all surfaces.

Vibram V100 HeelWorn for 7 months, current heel
Traction
Durability

Wearing as expected

Final thoughts

Good Value
Would Recommend

If you're looking at the Nicks Urban Logger, but don't feel like waiting 6 months, and spending over $600, you need to give these a shot. The Black Label leathers are all excellent, and awesome value. I think people are sleeping on these.

Written by ZelieDad
View 1 comment

Shop similar

Affiliate Links

More like this