Reviews

Boot and shoe reviews from real owners. Honest evaluations of quality, construction, sizing, fit, comfort, durability, and patina development.

The Rowdy Journey. Final thoughts.

Drew's 6" Contractor Captoe in Rowdy Smooth
By AR • April 1, 2025"What began as a simple recommendation from my podiatrist for wider toeboxes and better foot support unexpectedly led me to confront my own perfectionism through a pair of boots that weren't even my first choice. The minute I opened the box containing those Drew's contractors boots in "Rowdy" leather, disappointment washed over me—a feeling that would eventually transform into an unexpected lesson in acceptance. When my original order was unavailable, Drew's/Baker's offered these "Rowdy" leather ones instead. Opening the box, I was immediately skeptical. The pale, sickly color made me wonder if I'd made a mistake accepting the replacement. The leather on the right boot looked perfect, with a nice stiff temper that felt reassuring, but the left had a quarter with loose grain and no temper - something that bothered me considerably given my attention to detail. I nearly returned them but little did I know then that this very imperfection would later become a lingering reminder of something valuable. A simple conditioning transformed their appearance, bringing life to the natural brown leather and giving me hope they might work out after all. The initial break-in wasn't particularly difficult, just a period of adjustment as the high arches found their place against my feet. Each day they molded more perfectly to my stride, gradually transitioning from stiff newcomers to trusted companions. The second month marked a visible shift as the leather's true character began to surface. It creased readily, folding into patterns dictated by my stride, a stark departure from its initial pale and disappointing hue. It deepened into a rich, complex brown patina that seemed to gain life with every wear. The real revelation came with polishing: the toe caps, though scuffed and marked by daily encounters with furniture and chair casters, began to hold light differently. They developed a depth that caught the light with a quiet gloss. Sharing monthly progress photos with the community turned into a ritual I came to love. Seeing others’ boots—scuffed, creased, and beautifully imperfect—mirrored my own shift from critique to acceptance. Their journeys, posted alongside mine, softened my fixation on flaws, adding a layer of connection to my growing appreciation. What I've come to appreciate most is their versatility. The Rowdy leather develops such distinctive character with its creases and folds, yet becomes dark enough when polished that it dresses up surprisingly well. While they're not exactly formal footwear, the four-row stitched toe-cap adds enough refinement for slightly dressier occasions. At the same time, they've proven themselves on a couple of hikes, performing admirably in a way that good functional boots should—becoming unremarkable and simply extensions of my feet. I find myself looking forward to future adventures with them, whether urban or wilderness. The act of caring for them brings me back to those childhood days of shining my school uniform shoes for the morning inspection, which grounds me and connects me with my past at the start of each day. The natural leather has aged remarkably, developing a shine on the toes and heels that catches the eye and tells stories of our journeys together with the rolls and folds making a map of the experience shared. Six months in, these boots have become a sort of leather-bound therapist allowing me to reflect on and moderate my natural tendencies. I tend to obsess over technical details at work, a habit that seeps into everything else. The asymmetry and difference in the boots that I first noticed still echo in my mind occasionally, yet I've found more satisfaction in accepting them as they are than in wishing for what they could have been. A small daily reminder that perfection makes a poor prerequisite for appreciation...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: The Rowdy Journey. Final thoughts.
Read the full review

Just love my hand-made Service Boot in Horsebutt, and watching the character develop every day.

Al's Attire Hand Made Type 1 Service Boot in Horween Brown Chromexcel Horsehide
By LeeRoss • April 1, 2025"These boots have been with me through everything—from the desk to the dirt. They’ve worked as hard as I have—and earned every bit of character along the way...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Just love my hand-made Service Boot in Horsebutt, and watching the character develop every day.
Read the full review

Natural Dublin, The heritage leather that could...

Nicks Builder Pro, MTO in Horween Natural Dublin
By ShnyHntr91 • April 1, 2025"09/26/24 - Hurricane Helene made her devastating landfall in the South Eastern part of the U.S. dumping more than 40 trillion gallons of water upon the North Carolina, Tennessee border. Max sustained wind 140 mph. 10/05/24 - Hurricane Milton followed suit in St. Pete, Florida. Max sustained wind 180 mph. This pair of Natural Dublin, Builder Pro's were carried around from bucket truck to hotel room for six days before they were thrown into the carnage that was Hurricane Helene and Milton. These Builder Pro's started life off hard and fast, building powerlines across the country. From storm events such as the twin major hurricanes mentioned above, to lake effect snow and ice storms in Upstate New York. Climbing poles and digging holes to set new poles were frequent tasks throughout the restoration efforts. One thing to note was the hellish terrain this pair had to endure for the first three weeks of their life. From right of ways down in the Western North Carolina hollars, filled with huge, fallen pine trees in sea of unforgiving briars. To back yards in South Western Florida where they navigated through an obstacle course of cypress trees, which lay snapped between backyard properties. After returning home, they experienced primarily bucket work, which can be quite the abrasive environment for any pair of boots. Copper and aluminum wire scraps are cut and typically discarded into the bottom of the bucket. They can be extremely sharp objects that are residing with your boots for hours at a time. Temperature ranges were all over the map from high 90°F in Florida to single digits in New York. As for weather, we got to experience a little bit of everything, from down pouring rain and heavy snow to a month long dry and dusty drought. They handled all I and mother nature could throw at them......"Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Natural Dublin, The heritage leather that could...
Read the full review