Reviewing before first wear.

nubsrproabout 8 hours ago
Nicks MTONicks / Wickett & Craig Overdyed "Fry Sauce"

Maker

Nicks Handmade Boots

Shop now

Model

MTO

Leather

Last

HNW Last

US Men's Brannock: 12B

HNW Last: 12B

Composite toe

Very snug with thick socks. Doubling up for break in has my feet losing circulation at times. Right foot is a bit more snug. It is snug around the top of my foot where the arch is or at the bottom of the tongue. Entire boot fits perfect otherwise.

Sole

Purchased from

Nicks Handmade Boots

Shop now

Order info

Cost: 780 USD

Availability: Limited Edition

Lead Time: About 2 months

More about this item

November 2025 Sample sale leather from Nicks Haven't worn outside until March 16th 2026

Why did you choose this item?

Availability: Limited Edition
Style
Workplace Needs
Other

Needed safety toe and non slip for work. Chose leather based on style.

How did you determine your size?

HNW Last: 12BUS Men's Brannock: 12B
Online Guide
Sized by Maker
Sized Online
Brannock Measurements
Sized in Person

Used Nick's size guide and completed red wing sizing in-person to help validate sizing

What was the ordering process?

Purchased from Nicks Handmade BootsTotal cost: 780 USD Lead time: About 2 months
Customer Service
Online Store
Discount
Other
Direct Message

Ordered online. Had customization completed with costumer service on reddit, phone, and email.

Use & wear

Leisure
Other

I've not worn these at all outside. Have only been wearing a few times after work to break in. Have been wearing thick darn tough socks and removed false tongue to speed up the break in before needing to wear for 10+ hours each day.

Leather

Nicks / Wickett & Craig Overdyed "Fry Sauce"
Break-In
Color Change

The break in has been fairly quick given i haven't worn them outside and mostly have just been lounging around. The boots have become form fitting. Im already starting to see little yellow spots around the threads from bumping them on furniture.no care routine so far as it's not needed yet. I do have cedar shoe trees i put in them.

Fit

HNW Last: 12BUS Men's Brannock: 12B
Socks
Length Feels Right
Volume Feels Right
Ball Feels Right
Satisfied with the Fit

They initially were very hard to get on. I had the same issue with my military issued boots. I have high arches and the black webbing for the tongue barely stretches enough to get my foot in. This gave me some pause initially as I was worried they wouldn't fit. They are very snug at the bottom of the tongue as this it's the thickest part of my foot apparently. By wearing thick socks and Doubling up on socks, tightening these as much as possible and removing the false tongue. They have started to fit a lot better. The tightness isn't noticeable anymore and I don't need to double up on socks any longer. The padded collar is still pretty tight but I haven't been lacing the final eyelet which could be delaying this part of the break in. The length is perfect and there is some wiggle room with the composite toe.

Craftsmanship

Nicks MTO
Hardware
Construction
Finishing
Durability
Stitching
Design
Other

Zero issues. The padded collar is full leather from what I can tell. Definitely can't see it deteriorating. The pull loop is firm and feels good to utilize it. I can see some yellow around the laces and can tell these will patina nicely.

Sole & heel

Comfort
Traction
Design

Oil and slip resistant. Definitely very comfortable and don't see myself having any issues with traction when I start wearing them st work. Will see how they hold up over time.

Final thoughts

Would Recommend

Nicks has great costumer service and there subreddit is a great resource for first time boot owners. Part of why I chose this boot. I can't wait to patina and learn about how to take better pictures of my boots.

Written by nubsrpro
View 1 comment

More like this

No reviews yet.