A pleasant and enjoyable journey in a pair of Oak Street Trench boots.

Spoonover 1 year ago
Oak Street Bootmakers Trench BootTempesti Walnut Overdye Camello Asportabile

Maker

Oak Street Bootmakers

Shop now

Model

Trench Boot

Leather

Last

Elston Last

US Men's Brannock: 13D

Elston Last: 13D

Sole

Heel

Purchased from

Oak Street Bootmakers

Shop now

More about this item

First pair of Oak Streets and hoping for a dramatic change with the overdyed leather.

Use & wear

Office Work
Leisure
Snow
Cold Temperatures
Dry Climate
Hot Temperatures
Wet Conditions
Travel

These were a near constant companion every day with me at work. That is why you can see the strong "office" patina on these boots. These were a part of my life for the last 6 months and accompanied me on all my adventures. -Hiking around Acadia and then Vermont and New Hampshire -When I met my current significant other, I was wearing these boots. -When I visited family for the holidays, met my new niece for the first time, and traveled to my brother's wedding, i was wearing these boots. Like every year, these dome boots have a place in my heart, given the life events that they were apart of and will be in the rotation because of it for many years to come.

Leather

Tempesti Walnut Overdye Camello Asportabile
Patina Process
Durability
Care Routine

The break-in of this Tempesti leather was fairly easy, especially once the shaft loosened up and conformed to my ankle. The leather has resulted in a beautiful looking boot. The overdye gave way to really show the wear patterns unique to my feet. The leather was extremely resilient and took a beating and was only conditioned once at the end of the dome. Though I would brush the boots at least once a week.

Fit

Elston Last: 13DUS Men's Brannock: 13D
Arch
Comfort
Length Feels Right
Volume Feels Right
Ball Feels Right
Satisfied with the Fit

The shape of the last is comfortable, and I personally didn't have any major issues. I do think the design could benefit from additional arch support for my particular feet, and while I haven't added one, maybe a delta arch could be nice.

Craftsmanship

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot
Design
Construction
Finishing

Overall, the trench boots construction held up. There is a section where the split wealth was sanded down during the manufacture of the boots and is a defect, but nothing that affected the durability of the boots. I had heard and seen horror stories from other SDP members in the past, but these took a beating and kept going.

Sole & heel

Dainite Studded Sole BlackAlmost 2 years, current sole
Durability
Traction

I have had no issue with the dainite soles, they have held up and still have life left in them. I will note that after heavy rains and the worn down state at the end of the dome, they can be slightly slick compared to when new.

Low Block With Studded Top LiftWorn for almost 2 years, current heel
Durability
Traction

The toppling has held up throughout the dome without issue. It will need to be replaced with additional wear in the near future, but that should be expected with the miles I have put on them.

Final thoughts

Would Recommend

These trench boots surprised me, I have thoroughly enjoyed wearing them for the last 6 months. I will admit i was nervous given the issues other SDP members have had with Oak Street's in the past. However, other than a slightly sanded/damaged welt that didn't affect the durability of the boots, I didn't have any other issues with my pair.

Written by Spoon
Be the first to write a response

Shop similar

Affiliate Links

More like this

Overall nice boots but the last makes for a difficult fit for me.

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot in Horween Natural Indigo Chromexcel Roughout
By ShawnParr • April 5, 2024"Worn almost every day for the past 6 months. I’ve been trying to walk more to get in shape and most days I walked between 3 to 5 miles...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Overall nice boots but the last makes for a difficult fit for me.
Read the full review

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot in Horween Natural Chromexcel
By alamacchia2 • April 5, 2024"These natural CXLs from oak street bootmakers are my first pair of Goodyear welted service boots. I wanted the most classic of classic leather tones and silhouettes. After a few hours of research in late 2022, I came across the Stitchdown Instagram where I began to learn more than I thought I would about boots and shoemaking. To say the least, I am now hooked on the study and breaking in of boots. I love every aspect of it. After I bought this pair, I decided to save them for the following year’s thunderdome, which left a vacancy in my newly found obsession. I quickly went right back to Instagram, YouTube, and many boot review sources, and landed on a dressier silhouette for my wedding. My first kudu pair. The Lake shore boot from oak street bootmakers. Then, determined to expand my collection, I acquired the Alden Indy for my rehearsal dinner. Lastly, while on our honeymoon in Japan, my wife and I picked out matching pairs of red wing moc toes. I think I’m pretty set for a while… at least on brown tones. Time for some black boots. Anyways, my journey in the thunderdome pair has been a special experience. I’ve toyed around with laces, boot conditioners, photography strategies, and most importantly, time spent in the actual boots. Mainly, I wear them to work every day. I am in sales and cover a large portion of the Midwest, so these trench boots have seen many miles in a car, on a plane, and on cement. Grabbing a pair with the brogue cap toe made them pass for dress shoes at every stop. They have served me well. On the weekends, this trusty pair traveled to Big Sky, MT, Lake Tahoe, and Burlington, VT. While those trips were extraordinary, the final 2 week honeymoon run in Japan took the cake. Averaging 20,000 steps per day, my wife and I took the notice in the final month patina. Needless to say, I now have a beautifully broken in, overly comfortable, and story collected pair. Thank you for starting this community. I am excitedly looking forward to thunderdomes for years to come. Anthony..."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot
Read the full review

Cxl natural is such a comfortable wear

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot in Horween Natural Chromexcel Roughout
By Dannflow • April 3, 2025"Wore these 4 to 5 times a week for 6 months..."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Cxl natural is such a comfortable wear
Read the full review

Solid boot and a decent value all things considered.

Oak Street Bootmakers Trench Boot in Horween Natural Chromexcel
By boogieshafer • April 3, 2024"Office worker..."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Solid boot and a decent value all things considered.
Read the full review