My first pair of engineers in a Nick's and Murawski collab.

SpoonApril 5, 2025
Nicks PullmanHorween Black Waxed Flesh
Timeline photo 1
Worn 6 months
Timeline photo 2
Worn 5 months
Timeline photo 3
Worn 4 months
Timeline photo 4
Worn 3 months
Timeline photo 5
Worn 2 months
Timeline photo 6
Worn about 1 month
Timeline photo 7
Worn less than a day

Maker

Nicks Handmade Boots

Shop now

Model

Pullman

Leather

Last

HNW Last

US Men's Brannock: 13D

HNW Last: 12.5D

Sole

Heel

Purchased from

Nicks Handmade Boots

Shop now

More about this item

This is the Nicks x Carl collaboration engineer. However, due to my boot size, Nick's was unable to fit the original v-bar half sole to the boot. Given that constraint, Nick's worked me, and we changed the configuration to feature a leather outsole.

Use & wear

Office Work
Leisure

These were mostly subjected to office work, no real intensive testing took place at the test track to subject these boots to more of the elements. These boots were also worn to events with family and friends (i.e. Oriole's playoff game, holiday gatherings, etc.)

Leather

Horween Black Waxed Flesh
Color Change

There has not been much change with the leather over time. I have questioned since I received the pair, whether I actually received Waxed flesh as certain panels certainly feel like cxl. However, I have been assured by Nick's, and with some more wear, maybe I will get some change on the boots. Though, they do look good as they are.

Fit

HNW Last: 12.5DUS Men's Brannock: 13D
Comfort
Length Feels Right
Volume Feels Right
Ball Feels Right
Satisfied with the Fit

I like the fit of the HNW last for me at 12.5D once my foot is in the boot. My only real issue is when I go to remove the boots. I have noticed myself questioning if I really wanted to wear the boots knowing the struggle that would ensue when removing the boots. Especially, if I wore slightly thicker socks. There is that point in the shaft of a laceless boot where your instep and heel hit the transition from lower boot to shaft that was tight on these (especially when brand new).

Craftsmanship

Nicks Pullman
Construction
Design
Finishing
Durability

I think the design of Nick's engineer boot results in a good-looking boot. I did have an issue with a tear in the panel of my boots. Nick's offered to rebuild the boots, but after such long, wait to get my murawski collab engineers. I opted instead to take a slight refund for the defect in the production of my boots. It is a testament to Nick's that it has not gotten worse, though there were times I wondered if this was they day a catastrophic failure would occur.

Sole & heel

Leather SoleAlmost 2 years, current sole
Durability
Comfort

I personally really enjoy leather soles. It has been extremely comfortable. I have not needed toe taps on other boots, but this pair would benefit from them being installed during to wear at the toe. I plan to have them installed, and the sole should last quite a bit longer before a resole is needed.

Block Heel With Quabaug Top LiftWorn for almost 2 years, current heel
Durability

The quabaug top lift has held up, with no issues and minimal wear.

Final thoughts

Other

I have enjoyed the boots and obviously kept them, but if I were to do it again, I would have taken up Nick's offer to rebuild them and just accept that it would have been another year before I got them back. They can be difficult to remove with certain socks, which has made me second guess wearing them on occasion. Overall, it's a good boot that, even with its flaws will last but may not be for everyone.

Written by Spoon
Be the first to write a response

More like this

A tough pair for a tough year

Nicks Pullman
By DrJohnCrunch • April 6, 2025"These Pullmans have been in every environment I could put them in. From daily wear in the hospital to walking the streets of NYC to snowy solo hikes throughout the winter they’ve stood up to it all. I started medical residency this year and I bought these boots as a bit of a gift to myself for taking the next step in my career. I also bought them knowing I would be wearing them daily in the hospital. I quickly became known as “the boot guy” both among my coresidents as well as the hospital staff and my patients. Even though I wear a mask most of the time people can identify me by the footwear. Not only did these boots support me physically on my feet daily but they also became a bit of a part of my identity, at least in the way that others could pick me out easily. Being daily work boots for a new physician, these boots have been in a lot of tough situations this year; they were there when I introduced myself as a physician for the first time, when I discharged my first patient after watching them recover under my care, when I had difficult conversations with patients and their families about tough diagnoses, when I have seen people through their final moments, and when I have been parts of emergency life saving situations. As silly as it may sound, through all of these new/scary/difficult situations, these boots have helped me feel grounded and solid through it all. They help me stand tall even during the longest work hours of my life and they help me crouch down to speak eye to eye with my patients when they can’t get up out of bed. These boots have also been part of some of the happiest times of my life. I got both engaged and married this year. I’m one of the lucky guys whose wife actually beat me to it and she proposed first. Even so, I proposed to her a few weeks later and these boots were on my feet when I got on one knee. These boots were also on my feet through the entire process of setting up and decorating our wedding venue and they were on my feet while we hiked the blue ridge mountains while on our mini-honey moon. I’ve been glad to have something that has linked all these occasions that I can continue to wear and cherish for years to come. Every time I slide these boots on, I know a new memory can be made...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: A tough pair for a tough year
Read the full review