If Not Cowboy, Why Cowboy Shaped?

grainandtwill4 months ago
Nicks PolouseSeidel & 7-8oz Chocolate
View album

Maker

Nicks

Shop now

Model

Polouse

Leather

Last

55 Last

US Men's Brannock: 11C

55 Last: 11D

The width is snug and the heel has a little more slip than I’m used to.

Sole

Heel

Purchased from

Nicks Handmade Boots

Shop now

More about this item

This is an early prototype of the Nicks Palouse western boot.

Use & wear

Office Work
Physical Work
Outdoor Activities
Leisure
Travel
Cold Temperatures
Hot Temperatures
Dry Climate
Wet Conditions
Snow

These boots have been attached to my feet since October 2024. Work, play, lounging around the house, travel, and running around outside with my kids. These boots have done it all.

Leather

Seidel
Patina Process
Care Routine
Break-In
Durability
Color Change

These were a prototype boot that I saved from being tossed into the trash, so I had no idea how these would hold up. We think the leather is from the 1990’s, belly cuts were used on the right boot, and the top was ripped a little bit. But this old Seidel leather really held up and showed how awesome it is. It got a little darker, picked up some indigo crocking, and developed a nice little shine. I’m really impressed with it. I think I cleaned and conditioned them 4 out of the 6 months. The more they got scratched up and dirty, the cooler the looked. But I gave them a nice clean and conditioned to celebrates the end of the competition. Break in was a breeze,

7-8oz Chocolate
Patina Process
Care Routine
Break-In
Color Change

This was a dead stock leather from what we think is the 1990’s. is. It got a little darker, picked up some indigo crocking, and developed a nice little shine. I’m really impressed with it. I think I cleaned and conditioned them 4 out of the 6 months. The more they got scratched up and dirty, the cooler the looked. But I gave them a nice clean and conditioned to celebrates the end of the competition. Break in was a breeze,

Fit

55 Last: 11DUS Men's Brannock: 11C
Comfort
Arch
Socks
Added Insoles
Length Feels Right
Volume Feels Right
Ball Feels Right
Satisfied with the Fit

These were kind of tricky to fit. They were my length but they were three sizes too wide. After a few days of experimenting with insole and sock thicknesses, I had them feeling like my normal size. These were my first pull on boot, first cowboy boot, and my first boot on the 55 last, so it took a week or two to figure out how to walk in them. I’m not sure how I’m supposed to go back to a moderate arch after experiencing The 55 last.

Craftsmanship

Nicks Polouse
Design
Construction

Back in 1990, my Uncle Joe came up from Utah to visit. While he was here, he asked if I wanted a pair of cowboy boots like his. I laughed and said no way. I was a teenager—there was no chance I was getting caught in cowboy boots. That was true… right up until I saw the Palouse. Unlike my uncle’s boots, the Nicks version doesn’t have showy leather, exotic skins, or flashy inlays. Just a solid, heavy-duty western-style boot. No bells, no whistles. Just built tough, built to work. Perfect for someone who wants that cowboy vibe without bringing attention to their feet.

Sole & heel

Vibram 700 Tygum V-Bar Full Sole BlackLess than a day, current sole

No problems with the sole or heel. It did what it needed to do.

PackerWorn for less than a day, current heel
Design
Comfort

This is my favorite heel on old boots that come in for repairs, but I’ve always been afraid to wear it. I’m all in on the packer heel now. It’s awesome!

Final thoughts

Would Recommend

Here are a few things I’ve learned wearing these boots: 1. Cowboy boots aren’t as intimidating as they seem—anyone can rock them. Seriously, just go for it. 2. These are my first slip-on boots, and I always thought the sizing process would be tricky. Turns out, it wasn’t! Even though these were three sizes too wide, an insole and slightly thicker socks fixed it. 3. The 55 high arch last has me hooked. I won’t be able to go back to the moderate arch unless a DeltaArch is in the boot. If you’ve been afraid to try a western boot, don’t. They’re not as intimidating as they look. I’m the most non-cowboy guy in the world and I rocked them. You can too!

Written by grainandtwill
Be the first to write a response

Shop similar

Affiliate Links

More like this

Reliably durable with thick leather and superb craftsmanship.

Nicks Ridgeline Hiking Boot in Seidel Max Support Walnut Smooth
By danjr92 • July 4, 2025"Mainly use these for backpacking, hiking, and camping trips...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Reliably durable with thick leather and superb craftsmanship.
Read the full review

First pair of Nicks. After 22 years of Whites. Very impressed after 6 months.

Nicks Builder Pro Moc Toe Steel Toe in Seidel 1964 Brown Smooth
By cjdigs • April 4, 2025"Worn at work 5 days a week over the last 6 months. Rain, snow, salt, and mud...."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: First pair of Nicks. After 22 years of Whites. Very impressed after 6 months.
Read the full review

Tough go at the Dome

Nicks TankerPro in Seidel WeatherShield Black Smooth
By ofdff • April 5, 2024"Well, the dome is officially over for me, but I had the feeling a month in that I was done. These tankers are my work boots, so the logical thought was the work category. After the 1 month update photos were uploaded, I immediately realized I was no match for the guys literally running their boots into the dirt every day. As a firefighter, and more specifically an engineer (driver), these boots have a little different use case than the others in the work category. They see 10 shifts a month, so they’ve only had 64 wears while in the dome (I don’t suck at math, but I do work some overtime). 10 wears per month is certainly a setback for getting the same results as everyone else, but there is a strict rule: Work boots stay at work (for good reason). Each shift has these boots on my feet for about 18 hours, and they have been incredibly comfortable the whole time! The weather shield black is a durable son of a gun, and hardly shows patina. Great for most situations, but not the dome. My ‘dirty’ is much different than most of the others in the work category. While they haven’t been caked in mud, hydraulic fluid, or fertilizer like some of the others, they’ve seen their fair share of filth. They’ve stepped in blood, sweat, and any other number of fluid/tissues you can imagine coming out of a body. They’ve stomped out burning trash after the ‘urban outdoorsmen’ were informed their kitchen was out of line with the current burn ban. Their toes have been buried in the dingy carpet of the local crack houses while we pump on chests, push narcan to reverse the overdoses, and try everything we can to bring someone back from the brink of death, even though we know it’s too late. These boots certainly have stories to tell, and even without winning this contest, I appreciate the dome. Without it, they’re just boots. The Dome gives us all a reason to stop and reflect on the past 6 months, as cheesy as it sounds, but I’m still thankful nonetheless. Good luck to all the other contestants!..."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: Tough go at the Dome
Read the full review

I used these boots for working in a warehouse and generally use.

Nicks Ranger in Seidel 1964 Brown Smooth
By Macedo • April 5, 2024"They were used to wrk in a warehouse and general use..."Read the full review
Thumbnail of review: I used these boots for working in a warehouse and generally use.
Read the full review