Best Reviews2024
Best of Patina Project
Browse top posts from the Patina Project community.Browse by
Month
November 2025October 2025September 2025August 2025July 2025June 2025May 2025April 2025March 2025February 2025January 2025December 2024November 2024October 2024September 2024August 2024July 2024June 2024May 2024April 2024March 2024February 2024January 2024December 2023November 2023October 2023September 2023August 2023July 2023June 2023May 2023April 2023March 2023February 2023January 2023December 2022November 2022October 2022September 2022August 2022July 2022June 2022May 2022April 2022March 2022February 2022January 2022December 2021November 2021October 2021September 2021
Best reviews of 2024
Standing the test of time
Red Wing 8-Inch Classic Moc in S.B. Foot Oro-IginalBy Longshot • April 7, 2024"I am an electrician, I work in snow, rain, dust, mud, concrete floors and anything else a jobsite throws at these things, and they are incredible work boots...."Read the full review
For what I wanted, these fit the bill exactly. No frills, easy pull on boot
Briselblack The Seventh Chelsea Boot in Maryam Brown HorsebuttBy gear • April 4, 2024"Everyday wear, doing errands, going out, causal to more formal. My lifestyle does not include a lot of business casual or formal wear, so these are plenty “formal” to me when I needed to dress up slightly...."Read the full review
My first TD, with the third pair of jumpers I made.
Allister Caine Jumpers #3 in Pecos RawBy Allister_Caine • April 6, 2024"Daily activities, mostly work for eight hours a day in shoe retail, riding my bike everywhere I need to go and the on or another walk into the city just to flex them because they are awesome...."Read the full review
A very well constructed shoe, but I screwed up sizing because I didn't check my last, so no inlays.
Allister Caine Chukka #2 in CowboyBy Allister_Caine • April 6, 2024"Spare time use, retail work use, sometimes a walk in the park...."Read the full review
Rust Kangaroo leather fit like glove from day one and gained unique character over time
Grant Stone Edward Boot in Incas Rust KangarooBy AGold • April 7, 2024"Everyday wear. This boot was very versatile. I could dress up for work (business casual), travel, take hikes in the woods. Held up well in rain, snow too. Note that it is a thin leather so did not provide a lot of warmth on colder days (thick socks required). Wore literally every day...."Read the full review
Boots that lived up to their reputation (despite a few QC issues)
Nicks Overlander in Seidel 1964 Brown SmoothBy DiscoBiscuits • April 14, 2024"I wore my Nicks as my primary footwear through out the dome. Whether I was walking into town, doing chores outside, running errands, or hanging out, these were my primary drivers. The only exceptions I made were when they were wet, needed a break, or it got too cold, these boots have no insulation so I switched to my snow boots for truly cold temps...."Read the full review
Leftie tighty righty loosey. -a love story.
Nicks Traveler in Seidel 1964 Brown SmoothBy fjaagewaage • April 3, 2024"I have used them for just about everything.
First week i aerated the lawn with a pitchfork. I regret two things: getting my new boots muddy and not wearing gloves.
Helping friends and family with car maintenance, oil change and repairs.
I still ride my moped to work everyday in rain, snow and salted ice roads. Clerking, moving boxes, pallets, assembeling, transporting and repairing different disability equipment.
They have been worn in the woods and on lighter mountain hikes.
Walking around my local city and on vacation in London taking film photographs...."Read the full review
Went in wanting a grey colored boot that was going to patina and came out with a grey brown red boot
Nicks Americana in Wickett & Craig Slate Double StuffedBy nad45 • April 4, 2024"I used these boots for everything including yard work. I said from the get go I wasn’t going to baby the boots I was just going to wear them and see how things turned out. This leather is pretty phenomenal in terms of its support, its durability, and its comfort one it is broken in.
Outside of everyday wear the single activity that I have used these the most for have been hiking. I went on at least one hike per month in them including day 1 for 5 miles or so. The most I did in a single day was a 13 mile hike.
I live in the desert so there tends to be a decent amount of rock scrambling and the thing that surprised me the most was how easy it was to get scuffs and scrapes out of the leather with just a little brushing with a horsehair brush...."Read the full review
Hard wearing dress wear
Grant Stone Ottawa Boot in Badalassi Carlo Natural MinervaBy kylocheff • April 11, 2024"I’ve worn this pair nearly everyday for 5 months, most of the time has been spent in my office, but I also went on hikes, did lots of gardening, and traveling...."Read the full review
Great first boot, except for a squeak!
Adelante The Havana in Chestnut Full GrainBy atgrey • April 3, 2024"I worked from home the majority of the Dome, but these made it to the office 2-3 times a week until February, and saw nearly all of my weekend wear, as well as many walks around the neighborhood and on paved trails in nearby arboretums.
Tried wearing them to shovel snow once, but didn't have enough traction to get the job done.
Most interestingly, my left foot was in a walking cast for the entire month of November, and you can see the effects of it being one month behind on Patina! Aside from one big scuff on the toe, the right boot is clearly more wrinkled/worn in..."Read the full review
A great all around boot that I am proud to own. Could survive daily wear with little need for care!
Nicks Ranger in Seidel 1964 Brown SmoothBy adosreis • April 5, 2024"I wore these boots nearly daily, throughout the winter, on ski trips to Canada, to my office through rain and shine, and on short-medium hikes. They been to breweries, bars and events. They were a pivotal companion these last couple of months!..."Read the full review
M43 boots with an elegant touch ☺️
John Lofgren M-43 Service Shoes in Shinki Black Teacore HorsebuttBy palletshots • April 4, 2024"did not really care about them and just wore them :)..."Read the full review
These boots will never wear out
Viberg Rigger in Unknown LeatherBy chrisx • April 3, 2024"These boots have taken me everywhere! As a hat maker I work from my home studio so my footwear gets gentle wear, however, over the thunderdome I took a position in the costume department at Cirque du Soleil and these were perfect for working backstage in the big top. They took me hiking, snow shoeing, dancing, and for miles and miles of walking. I’ve worn them with jeans, skirts dresses, overalls and shorts, there is really no occasion they don’t work for. I’m so unbelievably happy with how comfortable they have become, they are definitely my go to choice for footwear...."Read the full review
Smart lil’ Cookie
Grant Stone Edward Boot in Badalassi Carlo Natural MinervaBy wirywill • April 5, 2024"I mainly used it in the office taking care of the onsite IT infrastructure. I usually commute with my old fixed gear bike. When it rains, I usually catch a bus. Shoutout to the horrible English weather for speeding up the patina process...."Read the full review
