Best Reviews2026
Best of Patina Project
Browse top posts from the Patina Project community.Browse by
Month
October 2025September 2025August 2025July 2025June 2025May 2025April 2025March 2025February 2025January 2025December 2024November 2024October 2024September 2024August 2024July 2024June 2024May 2024April 2024March 2024February 2024January 2024December 2023November 2023October 2023September 2023August 2023July 2023June 2023May 2023April 2023March 2023February 2023January 2023December 2022November 2022October 2022September 2022August 2022July 2022June 2022May 2022April 2022March 2022February 2022January 2022December 2021November 2021October 2021September 2021
Best reviews of 2026
Time-tested, tried and true
Red Wing Iron Ranger in S.B. Foot Copper Rough and ToughBy DaveFromAccounting • April 5, 2026"These are my everyday day boots, running errands, getting groceries, going on dates, mowing the lawn. If I’m not at work, I’m wearing them...."Read the full review
Another year, another dome
Wesco Boss Engineer Boot in Maryam Muschio HorsebuttBy DrJohnCrunch • April 4, 2026"I wore these boots about 5 days per week for the entire 6 month period. They saw all types of conditions from prepped hospital operating rooms (with shoe covers on of course) to local dive bars to concerts to light hikes. Being in the northeast, they saw 2 record breaking blizzards in 1 year. They were on my feet when my car got stuck in feet of snow overnight and they were back on when I went to dig said car out a day later. They were on my feet while I stood and rounded for hours in the ICU and they definitely saved my feet, knees, and back. While I don’t work in as harsh conditions as many who participate in the dome, my boots still saw quite a bit of use and took everything I could throw at them and just got better and better. I can’t wait to keep wearing these for years to come...."Read the full review
Sneaker-like comfort, Steel-toe protection
Nicks BuilderPro in Seidel 1964 Brown RoughoutBy DaveFromAccounting • April 4, 2026"I wear them everyday for work, they’ve been through it all, nice sunny days, cold frozen days, rain, mud and snow. Covered in concrete and drywall dust...."Read the full review
2nd Year
Wolverine 1000 Mile Plain-Toe Boot in Horween Navy Olive TanBy bootsforlife • April 4, 2026"Everyday walking, shopping, meeting with friends and a few small hikes...."Read the full review
Country boots for a city kid
Crockett & Jones Radnor in Rust Scotch GrainBy doublekicks • April 4, 2026"Mostly city walking. In nyc. Worn 145 times. Wore them to jazz gigs 64 times. Mostly with suits then. I never did hard labor in them. No hiking. I wore them as much as I could. I wore them in snow and rain...."Read the full review
Beautiful Leather, Beautiful Boots
NF Bootmaker Fritz Boot in Wickett & Craig Burgundy Burnt HarnessBy morosoleatherworks • April 4, 2026"They've been worn daily since October, not overly hard but not babied, either. A great many bike miles are on them, through rain and snow, and some travel, as well...."Read the full review
Willie’s Boondockers
Willie's Handmade Boots Boondocker in Maryam Olive HorsebuttBy DinkyDog • April 4, 2026"I have taken this pair just about everywhere over the past 6 months. I work part time retail and as an academic advisor (nothing super strenuous lol). I wore these on my mile long trek across campus in mornings and on the sales floor in the afternoons. Outside of work, I hike and walk my dogs a good bit, these came along for the ride many of times. I took these up to Minnesota and knew York and wore them in snow during the major snow storm in NC. Given the wet conditions these were oiled atleast every 2 months...."Read the full review
Benjamin Button Patina: A Lesson in Lighting
Wesco x S&S Van Cleef III in Horween Natural EssexBy Doug • April 4, 2026"These are truly boots made for engineers - I’ve made it 6 months and I still don’t know how to tie my shoe laces...."Read the full review
An enjoyable first engineer boot experience.
Nicks Brakeman in Seidel 1964 Tan RoughoutBy Ferachi • April 4, 2026"Worn almost daily, a little bit of snow, rain and mud but nothing substantial. Had to apply some Smith’s wax to the edges of the midsoles and heel stacks a couple times...."Read the full review
Great Moc Toe and an Even Better Price
Jim Green Meander – Moc-Toe in Bronco Brown - Oily Pull UpBy sigben59 • April 4, 2026"Daily we’re through a Chicago Fall and Winter. Lots and lots of city walking through wet and slush and snow. Then in the office at work...."Read the full review
Hard wearing, good looking, and damn comfortable.
Nicks Work Chelsea in Horween Predator NaturalBy bamcg • April 4, 2026"These have carried me through the last six months in materials reclamation and reuse. I spent a majority of my time doing field work - driving, residential materials pickups, commercial pickups. We had an unfortunately warm and dry winter in CO so they mostly spent life in dry and dusty conditions with a few wet days thrown in the mix. I’ve been in and out of roll offs, forklifts, trucks, and my office chair averaging maybe 13k steps a day...."Read the full review
Solid patina monster
Caswell Lisbon in C.F. Stead Caramel Classic Oiled ShoulderBy pilechko • April 4, 2026"I've worn these almost every other day for the duration of the dome. Even through the worst of the winter. I didn't wear them for shoveling snow, I prefer roughout boots for that...."Read the full review
Favorite pair of engineers!
KREOSOTE PaRLOR SkAR in Wickett & Craig Russet Harness with Kustom Color TreatmentBy rawtofaded • April 4, 2026"I’ve worn them for just about everything...."Read the full review
These are the heaviest duty boots I've ever owned. My first PNW pair definitely lived up to the hype
White's Foreman Lace to Toe in Brown DistressBy MuttBarker • April 4, 2026"I work for myself doing carpentry work and live on a farm. So they've been worked hard, going up and down ladders, having debris fall on them on demo days, kicking dirt in holes doing fencing, even chasing escaped cows across the yard lol..."Read the full review
